Abstract

• This main purpose of this study was to assess the effects of two different types of ethics education on the moral judgement of clinical nurses. One type was free discussions among nurses with given specific moral issues and the other type was discussions guided by experts on specific moral issues. The study employed a quasi-experimental, nonequivalent pre test-post test design using two different control groups. The conceptual framework of the study was derived from the Kohlberg's Moral Development Theory (1969) and the Greipp's Ethical Decision-Making Model (1992). The data was collected during the period of October 14 through December 15, 1998. Sample consists of 32 nurses working in the ICU who met research criteria. 16 nurses were assigned to the free discussion group and 16 nurses to the group for the guided discussion with experts group. For the pre-test, the DIT which was developed by Rest (1984) and JAND by Ketefian (1998) were used with some modification by the author. After the education, only JAND was used to assess the changes in moral judgement. The collected data was analysed using SPSS PC program. The findings are as follows: 1. There was no significant difference between two groups in their general characteristics. Only difference which was statistically significant between two groups was that realistic score on Case 3/Medical Research and Autopsy was higher in the free discussion group. 2. Hypothesis 1: "There will be a difference on the moral judgement of nurses before and after they receive an ethics education". This hypothesis was supported partially. Those who had low scores on moral judgement before the education tended to have higher scores after the education on the same issues. And, after the education, the nurses tend to give lower scores on the dilemmas they had experienced frequently at work; while giving higher scores on those dilemmas they had no prior experience. 3. Hypothesis 2: "The effect of education may differ depended upon the moral development index [P(%)] score of nurses". The effect of education was different depend on moral development level. The group who's P(%) scores was low at the pretest has higher scores in realistic moral judgement after the education, while the groups with middle or high P(%) scores went down after the education. These changes were statistically significant in some cases, thus, the Hypothesis 2 was partially supported 4. Hypothesis 3: "The method of ethics education will have different effects on the moral judgement of nurses". Even though several nurses attended the guided discussion stated that the education program broadend their perspectives the difference between two groups was not significant and this hypothesis was not supported. In conclusion, both types of ethics education had helped the nurses to acquire the skills to deal some nursing dilemmas. The effects of ethics education may differ according to the moral development index - P(%) score. However, because of some of the limitations of this study, mainly small sample size, short term education, unable to control other variables which may affect moral judgement of nurses, further research is warranted.
• Keywords: Moral judgement; Ethics education; Moral development index; Ethical dilemma of nurses

Figure & Data

REFERENCES

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by  

• Effects of ethics education on moral sensitivity of nursing students
  Hye-A Yeom, Sung-Hee Ahn, Su-Jeong Kim
  Nursing Ethics.2017; 24(6): 644.     CrossRef
• The Effect of Biomedical Ethics Education Program for Nursing Students Freshman
  Gye Seon Jeong
  The Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education.2016; 22(3): 376.     CrossRef
• Nursing Students' Awareness of Human Rights and Influencing Factors
  Sun-Woo Hong, Ji-Soo Kim, Hye-Jin Hyun
  The Journal of the Korea Contents Association.2011; 11(6): 260.     CrossRef
• Performance Evaluation of Transmitting Brainwave Signals for Driver's Safety in Urban Area Vehicular Ad-Hoc Network
  Jun-Mo Jo
  The Journal of the Korea Contents Association.2011; 11(6): 26.     CrossRef
• Validation of a Korean version of the Moral Sensitivity Questionnaire
  Sung-Suk Han, Juhu Kim, Yong-Soon Kim, Sunghee Ahn
  Nursing Ethics.2010; 17(1): 99.     CrossRef
• Hospital Nurses' Experience of Do-Not-Resuscitate in Korea
  Myungsun Yi, Sang Eun Oh, Eun Ok Choi, In Gak Kwon, Sungbok Kwon, Kyung-mi Cho, Youngah Kang, Jeonghui Ok
  Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing.2008; 38(2): 298.     CrossRef